The Problem With Choice
Choice Paralysis. The problem the big new entertainment media solutions like Spotify, YouTube, Netflix, HBO Go and others have is simple: Choice Paralysis.
Here’s a story: Most of my home media is on a home server that has a variety of clients (Xbox 360, Boxee, XBMC, Apple TV, PC) strewn about the house connected to TVs for access. This setup allows me to have every TV show, movie, and song I own available practically anywhere at any time. I asked my wife the other day if I should replace the cable box in the bedroom with a new Boxee box. She said no.
Her reasoning was sound: it’s too much choice. There comes a point where we use entertainment media as much as a distraction as it is a destination. After a certain amount of labor to get that distraction… it becomes a chore and not a distraction.
The best thing about cable (without the DVR, of course) and the radio is that you have defined choices. A limited amount. You can decide what you want to listen to by going through the <25 choices of decent channels and stations and landing on whatever is the most pleasing. These new options that give you thousands of choices each? It’s almost too much work for a minor distraction. If I flip on TBS while I’m eating dinner, that’s great. It’s easy. When I load up Netflix and have to pick out a movie or episode of a TV show, I’ve got to work hard for something I want to engage in passively.
What we need to see more of is not only the aggregation that we see now, but curation. Is curation the next phase in modern media channels? It could be. This is why we’re seeing a resurgence of things like StumbleUpon with their new(ish) iPad app. Curated content streams are lagging behind the the loads and loads of choices, but once they catch up things will change.
Update 8/22/11: More on the resurgence of StumbleUpon and how they’ve now overtaken Facebook in social sharing (funny what a dedicated, mobile, social sharing app will do for you) http://www.zdnet.com/blog/facebook/stumbleupon-passes-facebook-in-us-referral-traffic/2902